Super Indy Title Holders |
| Super Hentai became the first champion, defeating Christopher Daniels in the Super Indy Tournament I finals. | ||
| Styles was forced to vacate the championship for the Super Indy Tournament II in May 2003. | ||
| Cabana became the new champion by defeating Matt Stryker in the Super Indy Tournament II finals. | ||
| Styles became the champion by defeating Colt Cabana in the finals of the Super Indy Showdown Mini-Tournament. Styles later vacated the belt for the Super Indy Tournament III. | ||
| Sabin became the new champion by defeating Alex Shelley in the Super Indy Tournament III finals. Sabin later was forced to vacate the belt due to injury. | ||
| Keenan became champion by winning a "Four Way" Match over John McChesney, Josh Prohibition, and Petey Williams. Keenan later vacated the championship for the Super Indy Tournament IV. | ||
| McChesney became the new champion by defeating Low Ki in the Super Indy Tournament IV finals. | ||
| Low Ki later vacated the championship for the Super Indy Tournament V in April 2006. | ||
| Delirious became the new champion by defeating Troy Lords in the Super Indy Tournament V finals. | ||
| Gory became the champion by winning a "Second Chance Super Indy" Match over Troy Lords, John McChesney, and Eric Young. Gory vacated the belt later in the night for the IWC Super Indy Tournament VI. | ||
| Sweeney became the new champion by defeating Shiima Xion in the IWC Super Indy Tournament VI finals. | ||
| Lynn won the Super Indy Tournament VII on April 25th, but he refused the title, wanting to beat Larry Sweeney for it instead. Lynn beat Sweeney at Hell Hath No Fury 3 for the championship. | ||
| Gargano became champion by winning a "Three Way Elimination" Match over Jerry Lynn and Super Hentai. Gargano later had to vacate due to injury. | ||
| Delirious became champion by winning a "Four Way" Match over Jason Gory, Larry Sweeney, and Super Hentai. Delirious vacated the title for the Super Indy Tournament VIII. | ||
| Super Hentai became the new champion by defeating Justin Idol in the Super Indy Tournament VIII finals. | ||
| Xion became the new champion by winning a "Three-Way Elimination" Match over Azrieal and Johnny Gargano in the Super Indy Tournament IX Finals. | ||
| Justice won the championship by winning a "Three-Way" Match over Super Hentai and Shiima Xion | ||
| Fantastico became the new champion by defeating Super Hentai and El Generico in the Super Indy Tournament X Finals. | ||
| Facade became the new champion by winning a "Four-Way Ladder" Match for the vacated title over Matt Cross, Logan Shulo, and Hallowicked |